The nature of man is a subject that dates back centuries, though it is one that is still highly debated today philosophers, sociologists, and even sociobiologists have brought evidence leading to various conclusions to the table, so the question still stands mencius said that man’s nature is good, while hsun tzu argued from the opposite side. All in all, mencius believes the nature of man is essentially good but can diverge due to the lack of effort and care mencius uses quotes from kao tzu who thinks man's nature is neither good nor evil and examples from nature in order to strengthen his argument. So, mencius believed that though all humans are innately good, the realization of that good comes with self-cultivation and self-knowledge hsun-tzu could not accept mencius idealistic view of human nature, nor did he believe that heaven was the sole arbiter of human behavior.
Mencius claimed that human nature was naturally good man was born innocent and nave and it was only through time, war and experience that man became corrupt however, hzun tzu felt that human nature from birth was stained with corruption and full of evil and selfishness. Confucianism says that man is the center of the universe mencius believed that human nature is intrinsically good, and each person should try to recover the original good nature by doing these things one is able to become a good leader. Human nature is good just as water seeks low ground there is no man who is not good there is no water that does not flow downward ” (mencius, book iv) from these two examples we can see that mencius could easily be called an extremist on his view of inherently good human nature another view of mencius is that righteousness is internal rather than external this can be compared to the views of confucius on filial piety.
Which indicated that mencius thought no man was born having an inherently bad human nature this can be backed up when mencius talks to kao tzu about human nature kao tzu thought that humans were like “whirling water,” that they do not show any preference for good nor for bad, just as whirling water does not.
Explanation of mencius's own doctrine that man's nature is good 1 the disciple kung-tû said, 'the philosopher kâo says, man's nature is neither good nor bad it follows that the nature of all men, like that of the sages, is good 1 mencius said, 'in good years the children of the people are most of them good, while in bad years the.
After reading mencius essay “mans nature is good” and hsun tzu’s essay “mans nature is evil” it made me realize that men are shaped by experience people are born with a blank mind with a desire of some knowledge. With good times bringing about good men, and bad times bringing about the opposite, i feel that mencius used an invalid argument for the nature of man being good, but an excellent argument on the theory of the “blank slate.
Confucius and mencius - human nature and proper order my account human nature and proper order essay human nature and proper order essay but still aspires to consider the effects of individual actions on the common good and not to just ignore the interests of society as a whole this has helped guide east asia through its long and.